What to Serve with Tomato Pie? Perfect Pairing Ideas
When you’re enjoying a delicious slice of tomato pie, you might be wondering, “What to serve with tomato pie?” It can be tricky to find the right sides that enhance the flavors without overpowering them. No worries, though! There are so many tasty options to pair with this savory dish. From fresh salads to hearty sides, there’s something for every taste. Plus, the great thing about tomato pie is its versatility, making it easy to customize depending on what you’re in the mood for.
First, pairing your tomato pie with the right sides can elevate the meal and make it feel complete. Whether you’re craving something light and refreshing or warm and comforting, there’s a perfect match out there. You’re going to love how these pairings balance the rich, savory flavors of the tomato pie. So, keep reading to discover the best side dishes and drinks to enjoy with your next slice of tomato pie!
Table of Contents
Fresh Salads to Pair with Tomato Pie

A Classic Caesar Salad for a Crisp Contrast
When you’re thinking about what to serve with tomato pie, a classic Caesar salad is a fantastic choice! The crisp romaine lettuce and creamy dressing create a perfect contrast to the rich, savory flavors of the tomato pie. First, the crunch of the lettuce pairs beautifully with the soft texture of the pie, making each bite feel fresh. Then, the Parmesan cheese and croutons add extra flavor and texture, enhancing the overall meal. You’re going to love how this salad lightens up the richness of the tomato pie.
Next, a Caesar salad is super easy to prepare. Toss together fresh lettuce, croutons, and a generous amount of Caesar dressing. Add a sprinkle of Parmesan for that extra kick. This pairing is perfect for balancing the hearty tomato pie, and it adds a nice dose of freshness to your meal. It’s a simple but satisfying way to enjoy your tomato pie!
Arugula Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette for a Zesty Kick
If you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, try an arugula salad with balsamic vinaigrette! Arugula’s peppery flavor pairs beautifully with the savory, tomato-filled pie. First, the slight bitterness of the arugula adds a lovely contrast to the sweetness of the tomatoes in the pie. Then, the balsamic vinaigrette adds a tangy kick that enhances the overall flavor profile. It’s the perfect way to cut through the richness of the tomato pie while adding a burst of freshness.
Next, this salad is quick and easy to make. Just toss arugula with a simple balsamic vinaigrette and you’re set. You can even add some cherry tomatoes or shaved Parmesan for extra flavor. This arugula salad is a light, zesty side that complements your tomato pie perfectly, and you’re going to love how refreshing it is!
Savory Sides That Complement Tomato Pie

Roasted Vegetables for a Hearty Addition
When you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, roasted vegetables are a perfect choice! First, they’re hearty and filling, providing a great balance to the lighter texture of the pie. You can roast a mix of vegetables like carrots, zucchini, and bell peppers. The natural sweetness from the vegetables intensifies with roasting, adding a delightful contrast to the savory flavors of the tomato pie. The crispy edges of the vegetables bring a nice texture to the meal.
Next, roasting vegetables is simple. Toss them in olive oil, sprinkle with your favorite herbs, and pop them in the oven. These veggies are not only healthy, but they also bring a rich, comforting flavor that pairs beautifully with the tomato pie. The combination is both satisfying and delicious, making it a wonderful addition to your meal.
Garlic Bread to Add a Crunchy Element
If you’re still asking yourself what to serve with tomato pie, garlic bread is an excellent option! The crispy, buttery texture of garlic bread makes it a delightful pairing with the soft, savory tomato pie. First, the rich flavor of garlic butter complements the tangy tomato filling in the pie. The bread adds a satisfying crunch that contrasts perfectly with the soft, flaky crust of the pie. You’re going to love how this crunchy side elevates your meal!
Next, garlic bread is incredibly easy to make. Simply spread garlic butter on slices of your favorite bread, toast them to golden perfection, and you’re all set. This side adds both flavor and texture to your meal, making it even more enjoyable. Garlic bread and tomato pie together create a warm, comforting meal that everyone will enjoy!
Light and Refreshing Pairings with Tomato Pie
Cucumber and Tomato Salad for a Fresh Twist
When you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, a cucumber and tomato salad is a great option! The cool, crisp cucumbers and juicy tomatoes offer a refreshing contrast to the rich, savory tomato pie. First, the fresh, natural flavors of the salad balance the tangy, hearty taste of the pie. Then, a simple drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of herbs like basil or oregano adds extra depth. It’s a light and vibrant pairing that complements the pie without overwhelming the palate.
Next, this salad is super easy to make. Just slice up fresh cucumbers and tomatoes, toss with a bit of seasoning, and you’re all set. You can even add a dash of vinegar or lemon juice for a tangy kick. The refreshing crunch of this salad is the perfect side to enjoy alongside a warm, comforting slice of tomato pie. You’ll love how it lightens up the meal while still adding lots of flavor!
Cold Gazpacho Soup to Enhance the Meal
If you’re looking for what to serve with tomato pie, cold gazpacho soup is another excellent choice! This chilled, vegetable-based soup is refreshing and light, making it a great complement to the warmth of the tomato pie. First, the cool, smooth texture of gazpacho offers a satisfying contrast to the baked, savory pie. Then, the flavors of cucumbers, peppers, and tomatoes in the soup enhance the taste of the tomato pie, making each bite more vibrant. It’s a combination that makes the whole meal feel fresh and balanced.
Next, gazpacho is incredibly easy to make ahead of time. Just blend together fresh vegetables, olive oil, and vinegar for a simple, healthy soup. You can even serve it with a little extra garnish, like fresh herbs or croutons, for added texture. This soup adds a cool, tangy touch that elevates the overall meal. You’ll love how it pairs with the tomato pie, creating a light and flavorful dining experience.
Hearty Side Dishes That Balance Tomato Pie
Creamy Mashed Potatoes to Complement the Richness
When you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, creamy mashed potatoes are a perfect choice! The rich, buttery potatoes complement the savory flavors of the pie, creating a satisfying meal. First, the creamy texture of mashed potatoes balances the more savory, tomato-filled pie. Then, you can add a touch of garlic, cheese, or herbs to make them even more flavorful. The softness of the potatoes pairs beautifully with the tender tomato filling, offering a contrast of textures.
Next, mashed potatoes are easy to make and can be prepared ahead of time for a hassle-free addition to your meal. They’re a filling and comforting side that everyone will love. Whether you’re serving them for a family dinner or a cozy brunch, mashed potatoes bring a hearty element to the table. This pairing is perfect for rounding out your tomato pie meal!
Sautéed Spinach for a Nutritious Option
If you’re still wondering what to serve with tomato pie, sautéed spinach is a great nutritious side! The earthy flavor of spinach complements the richness of the tomato pie while adding a healthy touch. First, sauté the spinach with a little garlic and olive oil for a quick and flavorful side. The spinach becomes tender and absorbs all the delicious flavors, making it a perfect contrast to the pie. You’ll love how it adds both color and flavor to the meal.
Next, sautéed spinach is not only healthy but also quick and easy to prepare. You can serve it alongside your tomato pie for a light, nutritious addition that doesn’t overpower the flavors. This green side is a great way to balance the richness of the pie while adding a pop of color and freshness to your plate!
Drinks That Pair Perfectly with Tomato Pie

Iced Tea for a Refreshing Match
When you’re thinking about what to serve with tomato pie, iced tea is a great drink to pair! The light, crisp flavor of iced tea is the perfect balance to the savory richness of the pie. First, the cool, refreshing tea cuts through the heartiness of the tomato pie, making each bite feel lighter. Then, whether you prefer it sweetened or unsweetened, iced tea complements the flavors without overpowering them. It’s the kind of drink that feels refreshing with every sip.
Next, iced tea is super easy to make! Brew some tea, chill it in the fridge, and serve over ice. You can even add a slice of lemon or mint for extra flair. This pairing is perfect for summer or any time you want a cool, refreshing drink to go with your tomato pie. You’ll love how well these two go together!
Lemonade to Add a Tangy Contrast
If you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, lemonade is another excellent choice! The tartness of fresh lemonade adds a zesty contrast to the rich, savory flavors of the pie. First, the sweetness of the lemonade balances the savory tomato filling, creating a refreshing and flavorful combination. Then, the citrusy taste of the lemon brightens up the meal and adds a little extra zing. It’s the perfect drink to complement the flavors in the pie.
Next, lemonade is easy to make and totally customizable. You can make it as sweet or tart as you like by adjusting the sugar and lemon ratio. Add some ice and a slice of lemon for a classic, refreshing touch. This pairing is a fun, tangy way to enhance your tomato pie meal and keep things exciting. You’ll love the balance it brings!
For more delicious recipes, explore What to eat with hummus, What to eat with apple pear salad and chicken.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What city is famous for tomato pie?
When you’re wondering what city is famous for tomato pie, the answer is definitely Philadelphia! First, tomato pie is a beloved dish in the Philly area. It’s often served as a rectangular, thick crust pizza topped with fresh tomatoes, cheese, and seasonings. This savory treat has a unique place in Philadelphia’s food culture, and locals enjoy it as a delicious snack or appetizer. You’ll find tomato pie served at many pizzerias and bakeries throughout the city.
Next, the dish is so loved in Philadelphia that it has become a true staple. It’s often associated with family gatherings and casual get-togethers. If you’re ever in the area, be sure to try a slice of this delicious, city-famous treat!
Is tomato pie a Pennsylvania thing?
Yes, tomato pie is definitely a Pennsylvania thing, especially in the Philadelphia area! First, it’s a staple in many local pizzerias and bakeries throughout the state. Tomato pie is distinct for its thick, crispy crust and its fresh tomato topping, making it different from traditional pizza. It’s commonly served at parties, gatherings, and local celebrations, showcasing the state’s love for flavorful, simple food.
Next, this iconic dish is so beloved in Pennsylvania that it’s often considered a regional specialty. Whether you call it “tomato pie” or “pizza rustica,” it’s a dish that has earned its place in the state’s culinary history. It’s a must-try when visiting Pennsylvania!
Are you supposed to refrigerate tomato pie?
If you’re wondering what to serve with tomato pie, you might also be curious about whether you need to refrigerate it. The short answer is yes, tomato pie should be refrigerated if you’re not eating it right away! First, like most leftover pies, it’s best to store it in the fridge to keep it fresh. Tomato pie contains cheese and toppings that could spoil if left out too long. So, placing it in an airtight container or wrapping it tightly with plastic wrap will help preserve its flavor and texture.
Next, when you’re ready to enjoy it again, you can reheat it in the oven or microwave. Reheating ensures that your tomato pie retains its delicious taste and crispy crust. So, be sure to refrigerate any leftovers and enjoy them at your convenience!
Is tomato pie a New York thing?
While tomato pie is more strongly associated with Philadelphia, it’s also popular in parts of New York! First, in New York, you’ll often find a variation of tomato pie served as a slice of pizza, typically with a thick, crusty base topped with fresh tomatoes, cheese, and herbs. While it’s not as iconic in New York as it is in Pennsylvania, it still holds a special place in many pizzerias, especially in Italian-American communities.
Next, New York-style pizza is more famous worldwide, but the tomato pie version still makes an appearance. So, while tomato pie may not be originally from New York, you can certainly enjoy it there as a delicious and nostalgic treat!
Wrapping Up: Delicious Pairings to Enjoy with Tomato Pie
Now that you know what to serve with tomato pie, it’s time to get creative with your pairings! From fresh salads to hearty sides, there are endless possibilities to complement the rich, savory flavors of tomato pie. Light options like cucumber and tomato salad or cold gazpacho soup bring freshness, while creamy mashed potatoes and garlic bread add a comforting touch. These sides help balance the richness of the pie and elevate the entire meal.
Don’t forget the drinks! Iced tea and lemonade are perfect beverages to pair with tomato pie, offering a refreshing contrast. Whether you’re enjoying a casual meal with family or serving it at a gathering, these pairings will make your tomato pie even more enjoyable. So, go ahead, try these delicious options, and get ready for a satisfying and well-rounded meal! You’re going to love how these sides bring out the best in your tomato pie.